Onshore vs Offshore Wind Energy: A Comparative Analysis

Last updated on March 31st, 2024 at 01:19 pm

Onshore vs offshore wind energy is a topic of much debate in the renewable energy industry. Both types of wind power have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and choosing between them depends on a variety of factors such as location, cost, and environmental impact.

While onshore wind power is more established and cost-effective, offshore wind power is rapidly gaining momentum due to its greater efficiency and potential for larger-scale energy production.

We welcome you to the ultimate showdown between onshore and offshore wind energy! In this article, we’re diving into the realm of wind power to unravel the intriguing differences and surprising similarities between these two titans of wind power.

So grab your windbreaker, hold on tight, and let’s embark on this exciting journey!

How does wind power work?

Wind power harnesses the kinetic energy of the wind and converts it into electricity through the use of wind turbines. Here’s a simplified explanation of how wind power works:

Capturing the Wind: Wind turbines are strategically placed in areas where strong and consistent winds are prevalent. When the wind blows, it encounters the rotor blades of the turbine. The shape and design of the blades are optimized to capture the kinetic energy of the wind.

Rotating the Rotor: As the wind flows over the rotor blades, it exerts a force, causing them to spin. The rotor blades are connected to a central hub, which is in turn connected to a shaft. When the blades rotate, they transfer rotational energy to the shaft.

Generating Electricity: Inside the wind turbine, the shaft is connected to a generator. As the shaft spins, it also rotates the generator’s rotor, which is surrounded by a stationary set of coils. This relative motion induces a magnetic field, generating an electric current within the coils.

Converting and Distribution: The electricity generated by the wind turbine is typically in the form of alternating current (AC).  It is then fed into the electrical grid for distribution to consumers.

Monitoring and Control: Wind farms often have monitoring systems in place to track the wind speed and direction. These systems provide data that helps optimize the performance of the turbines. Advanced control mechanisms, such as pitch control, adjust the angle of the rotor blades to optimize energy capture and ensure safe operation in varying wind conditions.

Onshore vs offshore wind energy comparison

What is onshore wind energy?

Onshore wind energy refers to generating electricity from wind turbines installed on land, typically in areas such as plains and hills.

Onshore wind farms are often found in less populated areas where the uninterrupted airflow allows for efficient electricity production.

In the United States, onshore wind energy has a rich history dating back to the late 19th century when wind power was used for various purposes like grinding grain and pumping water. Since then, it has evolved into a thriving commercial industry.

Currently, there are numerous operational onshore wind farms spread across the United States, contributing significantly to the national electricity grid.

For example, Alta Wind Energy Center in California with a total capacity of 1,548 megawatts (MW), and Horse Hollow Wind Energy Center in Texas with a capacity of 735 MW are the biggest onshore windfarms in the United States.

Advantages and disadvantages of onshore wind energy

Advantages

Reducing the Carbon Footprint

Onshore wind power is a true champion when it comes to reducing our environmental footprint. Unlike traditional fossil fuels, wind energy produces zero greenhouse gas emissions during operation, helping combat climate change.

It also reduces air pollution and dependence on finite resources, making it a vital player in transitioning to a cleaner and greener future.

The gentle whir of wind turbines harmonizes with nature, showcasing a harmonious coexistence between sustainable energy generation and preserving our precious ecosystems.

Affordable Renewable Energy

One of the standout advantages of onshore wind power is its cost-effectiveness. Over the years, advancements in technology, manufacturing, and infrastructure have significantly lowered the overall cost of wind energy production.

The energy generated from wind farms has become increasingly competitive with conventional energy sources, such as coal and natural gas.

This means that harnessing the power of the wind not only benefits the environment but also helps to reduce electricity costs for consumers, paving the way for a more affordable and sustainable energy future.

Swift Installation and Maintenance

The installation process for onshore wind farms is a remarkable feat of engineering efficiency. With streamlined construction techniques and standardized components, wind turbines can be erected relatively quickly compared to other large-scale energy projects.

Additionally, the maintenance of onshore wind farms is comparatively straightforward. Routine inspections, servicing, and repairs can be carried out with relative ease, thanks to the accessibility of the turbines on land.

This efficient installation and maintenance process ensures a swift deployment of clean energy and minimal disruption during maintenance operations.

Efficient Grid Integration

Compared to offshore wind farms, onshore wind projects have the advantage of shorter cable connections. The proximity of onshore wind farms to the electrical grid minimizes the need for extensive underwater cable infrastructure, reducing transmission losses and associated costs.

This efficient grid integration allows for a more straightforward and cost-effective connection, ensuring that the electricity generated by onshore wind farms reaches consumers more efficiently and reliably.

Job Creation

The growth of onshore wind power brings a gust of employment opportunities. Wind farms require skilled workers for various stages of development, including site selection, turbine installation, and ongoing operations.

From engineers and technicians to project managers and maintenance personnel, the wind industry provides a range of job opportunities that contribute to local and regional economic growth.

According to the Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC), the wind energy industry has generated nearly 1.2 million jobs globally until 2021 and it will create more than 3.3 million jobs worldwide by 2026.

According to the US Department of Energy,  wind power employs 120,000 Americans, and now provides enough energy to power 40 million American homes.

According to studies conducted by IRENA, it has been found that onshore wind energy projects typically require an average of 5.24 jobs per megawatt (MW) over the 25-year lifespan of a standard 50-MW onshore wind project.

This indicates the significant job creation potential associated with onshore wind, with each megawatt of installed capacity supporting a considerable number of employment opportunities throughout the project’s operational lifetime.

These green-collar jobs not only bolster the renewable energy sector but also invigorate local communities by creating stable employment and fostering a skilled workforce for the future.

Boosting Local Economies through Wind Power

Onshore wind power carries a breeze of economic benefits for local communities. Wind farm development injects substantial investments into the area, stimulating economic activity and generating revenue for local businesses.

From land lease agreements with property owners to the purchase of materials and services from local suppliers, the presence of wind farms creates a ripple effect, bolstering local economies.

Furthermore, the additional income generated by wind farm projects can be channeled into community initiatives, infrastructure development, and public services, providing long-term benefits to the region.

Disadvantages

Wind Speed Fluctuations

One of the challenges of onshore wind power is the variability in wind speeds. Wind patterns can fluctuate throughout the day and seasonally, affecting the consistent generation of electricity. However, advanced technologies and proper site selection can help mitigate this issue to some extent.

Lesser Power Generation

Compared to offshore wind farms or other renewable energy sources, onshore wind farms generally have a lower power generation capacity. The available land area and height restrictions for onshore turbines limit their capacity to capture wind energy on a larger scale. 

Intermittent Energy

Since wind is an intermittent energy source, the electricity generated by onshore wind turbines is not constant. This intermittency poses challenges for balancing the electricity grid and requires backup power sources or energy storage systems to ensure a consistent supply of electricity.

Public Acceptance and Opposition

Onshore wind projects sometimes face opposition from local communities due to concerns about visual impacts, noise pollution, and potential effects on property values.

The presence of large wind turbines on the landscape can alter the scenic view and disrupt the aesthetic appeal of an area, which can lead to resistance from nearby residents.

Noise generated by the rotating blades and mechanical components of wind turbines can also be a source of annoyance for those living in close proximity.

Additionally, there may be concerns about the potential impact on property values, as some individuals believe that the presence of wind turbines may decrease the desirability of surrounding properties.

Limited Potential for Large-Scale Expansion

As onshore wind farms are dependent on available land areas with suitable wind resources, there is a limit to their potential for large-scale expansion. In densely populated regions or areas with competing land uses, finding suitable sites for new onshore wind projects can become increasingly challenging.

This limitation can impact the growth of onshore wind energy and necessitate the exploration of other renewable energy sources to meet growing electricity demands.

Decommissioning and End-of-Life Management

At the end of their operational life, onshore wind turbines require proper decommissioning and disposal. This process involves dismantling and removing the turbines, restoring the land to its original state, and managing the disposal of components and materials.

Decommissioning can be complex and costly, requiring careful planning and adherence to environmental regulations.

What is offshore wind energy?

Offshore wind energy refers to the harnessing of wind power from wind turbines installed in bodies of water, typically in the ocean. Unlike onshore wind farms, which are located on land, offshore wind farms are situated in coastal or offshore areas where strong and consistent winds prevail.

These wind turbines are specially designed to withstand the harsh marine environment, including high winds, saltwater exposure, and wave forces.

The Hornsea 1 Offshore Wind Farm, situated off the coast of Yorkshire, England, holds the distinction of being the world’s largest operational offshore wind farm. With an impressive total capacity of 1.2 gigawatts (GW), it harnesses the power of wind through its 174 wind turbines.

 In fact, Hornesa 1 produces enough power to meet the electricity needs of over one million homes, making a significant contribution to sustainable energy generation and reducing carbon emissions.

Advantages and disadvantages of offshore wind energy

Advantages

Increased Energy Efficiency and Output

Offshore wind turbines benefit from stronger and more consistent winds compared to onshore locations, resulting in increased efficiency and higher energy output. The offshore environment provides unobstructed wind flow, allowing turbines to capture more energy and generate electricity at a greater capacity.

This efficiency improvement contributes to maximizing the utilization of wind resources and increasing the overall effectiveness of offshore wind farms.

Environmental Sustainability

Offshore wind power offers significant environmental advantages. By harnessing clean and renewable wind energy, it helps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and dependence on fossil fuels.

Compared to conventional non-renewable energy sources, offshore wind energy has a smaller carbon footprint and minimal impact on local air quality.

Additionally, offshore wind farms have the potential to conserve marine ecosystems by avoiding land disruption and preserving coastal habitats.

Expansive Construction Opportunities

One of the key advantages of offshore wind power is the availability of more space for construction. Unlike onshore wind farms, which face limitations due to land constraints and competing land uses, offshore locations provide vast expanses of open water.

This ample space allows for the deployment of a larger number of turbines, resulting in greater energy generation potential and scalability.

Reduced Visual and Noise Intrusion

Offshore wind farms are less intrusive in terms of visual and noise impacts compared to onshore installations. The turbines are positioned farther from the coastline, reducing their visibility from residential areas and preserving the aesthetic appeal of coastal landscapes.

Moreover, the sound generated by offshore turbines is dampened by the distance and the natural sound-muffling properties of water, minimizing noise disturbances for nearby communities.

Utilization of Larger Turbines

Offshore wind farms have the advantage of accommodating larger turbines due to the absence of height restrictions and the availability of stronger winds. Bigger turbines have larger rotor diameters and higher power capacities, enabling them to capture more wind energy and generate electricity at a greater scale.

The utilization of larger turbines contributes to improved energy production efficiency and cost-effectiveness in the long run.

Technological Advancements

Offshore wind energy drives technological advancements in the renewable energy sector. As the industry grows, there is continuous innovation in turbine design, foundation structures, installation techniques, and transmission technologies.

These advancements improve efficiency, reduce costs, and enhance the overall performance and reliability of offshore wind farms.

Job Creation and Economic Growth

The development and operation of offshore wind projects create employment opportunities. The construction phase requires a skilled workforce, including engineers, technicians, and laborers, stimulating job creation.

According to GWEC studies, the job requirement for offshore wind projects is estimated at 17.29 person-years per megawatt (MW) over the 25-year lifetime of a typical 500-MW offshore wind project. According to the US Department of Energy, the offshore wind industry will need an average of between 15,000 and 58,000 full-time jobs every year from 2024 to 2030.

Disadvantages 

Installation challenges

Building and installing offshore wind turbines can be technically challenging and require specialized equipment and expertise.

The logistics of transporting and assembling large turbine components at sea, often in deep water and harsh weather conditions, can be complex and time-consuming. These challenges can result in longer project timelines and higher costs.

Higher cost

Offshore wind projects typically involve higher upfront costs compared to onshore wind farms. The construction, installation, and maintenance activities in the harsh offshore environment require specialized equipment, vessels, and expertise, leading to increased expenses.

Additionally, the costs associated with grid connection and transmission infrastructure can be significant. However, advancements in technology and increased deployment are expected to drive down costs over time.

Maintenance and repairs

Offshore wind turbines are exposed to more challenging weather conditions and corrosive environments, requiring regular maintenance and repairs. Accessing and servicing turbines located far out at sea can be logistically complex and expensive.

Maintenance tasks, such as blade inspections, gearbox repairs, and electrical system maintenance, often require specialized vessels and trained technicians. The costs and logistical challenges associated with maintenance can impact the overall profitability of offshore wind projects.

Less local jobs

While offshore wind projects create jobs, the number of direct local jobs can be limited due to the specialized nature of offshore wind operations. The complex construction and maintenance activities often require highly skilled technicians and engineers, which may not be readily available in the immediate vicinity of the project.

However, offshore wind projects can still contribute indirectly to the local economy through supply chain opportunities, service contracts, and the development of local expertise.

Impacts on marine life

Offshore wind farms can potentially impact marine ecosystems and wildlife, including whales. The construction and operation of wind turbines, underwater cables, and associated infrastructure can create underwater noise and disturbance, which may affect marine mammal behavior, communication, and migration patterns.

Mitigation measures, such as careful site selection, noise reduction technologies, and monitoring programs, are employed to minimize the potential impacts on marine wildlife.

Subsea cable issues

Offshore wind farms require extensive subsea cables to transmit the generated electricity to the onshore grid. These cables can be susceptible to damage from natural events, such as storms and seabed movements, as well as from human activities like fishing or shipping. 

Similarities between onshore and offshore wind power

• Harnessing wind energy: Both onshore and offshore wind power involve harnessing the natural power of wind to generate electricity. Wind turbines are used in both cases to capture the kinetic energy of the wind and convert it into usable electrical energy.

• Renewable and clean energy: Both onshore and offshore wind power are sources of renewable energy, meaning they rely on a naturally replenishing resource—wind—to generate electricity. Unlike fossil fuels, wind power does not produce harmful greenhouse gas emissions or contribute to air pollution, making it a clean energy source.

• Technological components: Onshore and offshore wind power systems share similar technological components. Both utilize wind turbines, which consist of blades, a hub, a generator, and other mechanical and electrical systems. The principles of aerodynamics and electromagnetism are employed to convert the rotational motion of the blades into electrical energy.

• Energy production: Both wind power systems contribute to the generation of electricity. They can generate significant amounts of power, with larger wind farms having the capacity to supply electricity to thousands or even millions of homes.

• Job creation and economic benefits: Both types of wind power contribute to job creation and economic growth. The development, construction, and maintenance of wind farms require a skilled workforce, creating employment opportunities in various sectors, such as engineering, manufacturing, installation, and maintenance. 

• Environmental benefits: Both onshore and offshore wind power offer environmental benefits. By displacing the need for fossil fuel-based electricity generation, they help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate climate change. Wind power also contributes to the conservation of natural resources by reducing dependence on finite fossil fuel reserves.

• Renewable energy transition: Both onshore and offshore wind power play a crucial role in the global transition towards renewable energy sources. They contribute to diversifying the energy mix, reducing reliance on fossil fuels, and promoting a sustainable and low-carbon future.

• Government support and policies: Both onshore and offshore wind power sectors receive support from governments and policymakers. In many countries, incentives and regulations are in place to promote the development and expansion of wind energy, including financial incentives, feed-in tariffs, and renewable energy targets.

Differences between onshore and offshore wind power

• Location: The primary difference between onshore and offshore wind power lies in their location. Onshore wind farms are situated on land, typically in open areas such as plains, hills, or farmland. In contrast, offshore wind farms are located in bodies of water, usually in coastal areas or offshore regions.

• Wind resource: Offshore wind farms generally benefit from stronger and more consistent wind resources compared to onshore wind farms. The proximity to large bodies of water and the absence of terrestrial obstacles allow offshore turbines to capture higher wind speeds, resulting in potentially higher energy production.

• Construction and installation: Onshore wind farms are generally easier and more cost-effective to construct and install compared to their offshore counterparts. The logistics of transporting and installing turbines at sea, along with the need for specialized vessels and equipment, make offshore wind farm construction more complex and expensive.

• Turbine size and capacity: Offshore wind farms often use larger turbines with higher capacity compared to onshore wind farms. Offshore turbines can take advantage of the vast space available at sea, allowing for the installation of larger rotor diameters and taller towers. This enables them to capture more wind energy and generate higher power outputs.

• Environmental impact: While both onshore and offshore wind power have environmental benefits, they differ in their specific environmental impacts. Onshore wind farms may have local environmental effects, such as visual impact, noise, and the potential disruption of wildlife habitats. Offshore wind farms, on the other hand, can have environmental impacts related to marine ecosystems, including underwater noise, disturbance to marine species, and potential effects on migratory routes of marine animals.

• Cost considerations: Offshore wind power projects tend to be more expensive compared to onshore projects. The higher costs are attributed to the complexities of offshore construction, including foundation design, installation at sea, and maintenance challenges. 

• Grid connection: Onshore wind farms have relatively easier grid connection options, as they can be directly connected to existing onshore transmission infrastructure. Offshore wind farms require the installation of undersea cables to transmit the generated electricity to the onshore grid, adding additional complexity and costs to the project.

• Community engagement: Onshore wind power projects often involve closer engagement with local communities due to their proximity to residential areas. Offshore wind farms are typically located farther away from populated areas, reducing potential visual and noise concerns for nearby communities.

Conclusions

In the grand debate between offshore and onshore wind energy, it’s clear that both have their own merits and contribute to our clean energy revolution. Onshore wind farms offer us the advantage of lower costs, easier accessibility, and established technology. They’re like the reliable workhorses of the wind energy world, harnessing the power of the breeze in open fields and rolling hills.

But let’s not overlook the offshore champions! These wind farms located out at sea bring a whole new level of excitement. With their towering turbines and the vast expanse of the ocean as their playground, they have access to stronger and more consistent winds. And did you know they can house those massive turbines with larger capacities? It’s like having the heavyweight champions of wind energy out there, flexing their muscles.

Now, offshore wind power does come with its fair share of challenges. It demands higher upfront investments and requires more complex construction and maintenance activities. But hey, progress doesn’t come easy, right? We’re constantly pushing the boundaries of technology, finding innovative solutions to overcome these hurdles and make offshore wind energy even more efficient and cost-effective.

So, the real question is: why choose between onshore and offshore when we can have the best of both worlds? By harnessing the strengths of both types of wind energy, we can create a powerful synergy that maximizes our renewable energy potential. It’s like building a dream team where each player brings their unique skills to the table.

Sources:

1. Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC)
2. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)